Light vs. Ice: The Best Relief for Perineal Pain and Healing After Birth
The New Breakthrough in Postpartum Healing: Why Photobiomodulation Beats Padsicles for Perineal Recovery
Postpartum recovery can be challenging no matter how your baby arrives. For moms who experience perineal injuries like a tear or an episiotomy, the healing process can be slow and uncomfortable and can make breastfeeding more difficult if you’ve only been taught how to nurse sitting up. That’s why effective treatments for pain and swelling after childbirth are a must.
For years, cryotherapy (think ice packs) has been the go-to solution for reducing swelling and pain in those first critical hours after delivery. But what if there’s something better? A new clinical study has compared cryotherapy with photobiomodulation (PBM)—a cutting-edge therapy that uses light to promote healing—and the results are very exciting!
If you’re ready to learn about how PBM (also known as red light therapy) can speed up postpartum recovery and reduce discomfort, keep reading.
Let’s Break It Down: What is Cryotherapy?
You’ve probably heard of cryotherapy or cold therapy—it’s a simple and popular method for reducing pain and swelling. In fact, it was the core of the RICE treatment (Rest, Ice, Compression, Elevation) that many of us grew up using for sprains and other injuries. But in recent years, there’s been a shift away from using ice to heal injuries, and here’s why:
Cold therapy interrupts the body’s natural healing process by halting inflammation, which is actually a key part of recovery. When you get injured, your body kicks off the healing process with inflammation, signaling your immune system to repair the tissue. By applying ice, you temporarily stop inflammation, and while that might numb pain, it could also slow down recovery.
This is a big reason why experts are questioning the RICE method for muscular injuries—and even for postpartum recovery. Applying cold to reduce swelling may actually delay healing because it blocks the inflammation that your body needs to repair tissue.
Cryotherapy in the Study: How Was It Used?
In this study, 56 postpartum women who had experienced either grade I or II tears or an episiotomy during childbirth were divided into two groups—one receiving ice and the other receiving red and near infra red light.
Here’s how the cryotherapy treatment was applied:
Cold Application: A latex glove filled with crushed ice was placed directly on the perineal area for 20 minutes.
Timing: The treatment was administered within the first 12 hours postpartum—when pain and swelling are most intense.
Cryotherapy works by reducing blood flow to the area, which can decrease swelling and provide short-term pain relief. Sounds good, right? Well, while it did help reduce pain, the results of this study suggest there’s an even better option: photobiomodulation.
Enter Photobiomodulation: A Game-Changer for Postpartum Healing
So, what is photobiomodulation (PBM)? Unlike cryotherapy, which cools the body to reduce inflammation, PBM uses red and infrared light to stimulate cellular repair, reduce inflammation, and promote faster healing. And guess what? It does all this without interrupting the body’s natural healing process.
Here’s how PBM was applied in the study:
Red light (660 nm) was applied with a dose of 3 J/cm² at the injury site for 30 seconds per point.
Infrared light (808 nm) was applied at a dose of 6 J/cm² for 60 seconds per point. The light was focused around the injury to promote deeper tissue healing.
PBM works by boosting cellular energy (ATP production), which speeds up the repair process, reduces inflammation, and encourages healthy blood flow—all of which help the body heal faster. It’s non-invasive, painless, and doesn’t have the same drawbacks as ice or anti-inflammatory medications.
The Study’s Most Exciting Results: PBM Outshines Cryotherapy
Now, here’s where things get exciting. The study found that PBM outperformed cryotherapy in almost every way, offering better pain relief and faster healing. Here are the key findings:
Superior Pain Relief
In the PBM group, pain scores dropped from 5.1 to 2.0 immediately after treatment and to 0.7 after 24 hours. Yes, you read that right—almost no pain after just one day!
The cryotherapy group saw pain scores drop from 4.7 to 3.2 immediately after treatment, and to 2.5 after 24 hours. While this was still helpful, the results were nowhere near as dramatic as with PBM.
Better Healing
PBM not only reduced pain but also improved healing significantly. The REEDA scale (which measures redness, swelling, and wound healing) showed the PBM group’s score drop from 3.8 to 2.4 after 24 hours, while the cryotherapy group’s score only went from 3.2 to 2.9. PBM led to more effective healing with less swelling.
No Interruption of the Inflammatory Process
One of the most exciting things about PBM is that it supports the body’s natural healing process instead of halting inflammation like ice or NSAIDs. PBM promotes cellular regeneration and collagen production and increases blood flow, speeding up recovery without interfering with the inflammation needed for tissue repair.
Why This Matters for Postpartum Moms
For postpartum moms dealing with the discomfort of perineal injuries, PBM offers a new frontier in recovery. Here’s why this study is such a game-changer:
Faster Recovery: Moms can experience rapid pain relief and faster healing, which means getting back to feeling like yourself sooner.
Non-Invasive and Drug-Free: PBM is painless and doesn’t interfere with breastfeeding or come with the side effects of medications.
Long-Lasting Benefits: Unlike ice, which offers short-term relief, PBM promotes long-term healing by working with your body’s natural processes.
This study shows that PBM could be the new gold standard for postpartum care, helping moms recover more quickly and comfortably than ever before.
What Kind of Light Should I Get?
In the study, the DMC Therapy EC device was used for but it’s over $2000 - but the good news is you can find more affordable options that will provide similar wavelengths for a fraction of the cost with LEDs. I am an affiliate for Hooga for many reasons detailed here. When you purchase through my website - reach out and I’ll create a tailored protocol based on your unique needs. I like the Hooga torch as it also includes blue wavelengths which are antimicrobial (helps keep wound potential infections at bay) and not much energy is required for superficial skin healing.
So if you’re due your baby soon and are looking for ways to accelerate healing and reduce pain, photobiomodulation might be the solution you’ve been waiting for. While cryotherapy has long been a standard treatment, PBM offers a faster, more effective option that works in harmony with your body’s natural healing process.
As this study shows, PBM outshines cryotherapy in reducing pain, swelling, and promoting faster recovery.
I’ve shared lots of free red light resources to support your pregnancy and postpartum health on my page.
Questions? Reach out anytime!
Tracy
